After Watching Win American Idol I Never Doubted His ​medal Again
I'm with Simon.
Alarm: Spoilers
Far also much of this bear witness is pathetic. From the cheap looking phase to the under choreographed numbers to the sugary judges, this show frequently misses the marker. But there are some fine singers. Near of them accept the pipes, it's simply control that they lack, a good singer knows when to not utilize their powerful vocalization. Sometimes, in some numbers, you lot tin meet what the show was intended to be, a display of top talent fighting for suspension. The high note for me is the unflinching honesty of Simon Cowell. While Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul spent too much time glad handing decent performances, but Simon keeps his emotions in cheque, trying to dispense advice. Too oft he is put down past window dresser Ryan Secrest for not having fun. It's refreshing to listen to someone try to honestly dissect a operation and for those who think he is too harsh, a lot of people will be telling these contestants that they aren't proficient enough, it'southward time for them move past their natural talent and grow thicker skin. The greatest performers have a work ethic to match their talent, that is what should be idolized.
8 out of 9 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Yer basic beloved/hate human relationship - more than detest than dear past 2013
I've watched every episode of this bear witness from its inception, and, sadly only not surprisingly, I take seen it go more and more cheesy as the years get past.
For starters, Seacrest has to go. If you look upwardly the word smarmy in the lexicon, yous will come across his picture. And the judges are all a joke at this point - they've become caricatures of themselves, it seems, and nothing they have to say ways anything, nor do the viewers' votes actually count, since I believe the producers of the show will not take someone win whom they do non approve of (pregnant someone they can't control). The contestants are even so good, though, which is why I nevertheless watch: I'g a sucker for a talent show and I do dearest seeing someone do really well, as Jordin is doing this year. And allow's face it, the show is an incredible spectacle - the mod equivalent of, say, the gladiators in the Colosseum.
Concluding night, they kicked off the "Idol Gives Back" thing, where, for every vote cast, x cents would exist donated by the shows' sponsors - Ford, Coca Cola, and A T & T - toward the world's hunger crisis. Seacrest stood there, in all his sanctimonious smarminess, preaching to united states nearly how we were non just voting this week, we're "saving lives." I'm all for ending hunger in all countries of the globe, start with our country, don't go me incorrect, but this to me feels like a very underhanded and sleazy mode to obtain more than publicity for the show.
The corporations in question have plenty money to fully stop all world hunger if they wanted; they do not need our votes to contribute to that cause. And it would be a tax write-off for them, to boot. By telling people they are "saving lives" by voting, the producers of the show (and Seacrest, as their shamelessly pathetic talking caput - he's similar Max Headroom without the soul) are implying that the contrary is true, as well: if you don't vote, you are NOT saving lives.
About the show itself: the worst affair is how they never allow the contestants sing a whole song, they have to condense their song into a minute and a one-half, and then they get criticized for not having enough feeling or plenty confidence or enough personality, blah blah blah. A song has to be complete in guild for it to legitimately 'live' - the emotion or feeling of it has to build and you cannot genuinely do that when yous're forced to cut out about of it. They have time on the prove for all sorts of crap, merely they can't make fourth dimension for the performers to actually SING. I commend anyone who can come on week subsequently week and manage to requite a credible functioning under these conditions, something the judges don't seem to acknowledge or appreciate.
Where volition it all finish? I predict a few more seasons, and then hopefully the network will take the show off before it deteriorates into an fifty-fifty tackier circus than it'south already become.
Added iii/6/xiii ~ This flavour hopefully will be the last. Brutal.
Added 2/21/14 ~ Still going' on. It'southward a joke at this bespeak; everybody feels information technology. Keith Urban, J-Lo and Harry Connick Jr. are very strange judges, not much credibility there, and of course Seacrest is notwithstanding on board, still smarmy equally ever. This time the question is : WHEN will information technology all finish? I couldn't even sentry the preliminary episodes this year, the whole option procedure and the Hollywood thing, the group claiming, blah blah apathetic. Cannot stand how they play with the contestants' heads, when they call them in to That Room, making them walk from the lift all the way to their desk in Outer Mongolia, only to torture them with the 'well, you know nosotros can't pick everyone and we're really sorry, we don't know how to tell yous this...(long dramatic pause)...but y'all're going through!" Pathetic.
44 out of 70 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Elegant proof that the RIAA still does not become "information technology"...
The basic premise behind American Idol, a talent bear witness in which a large number of contestants battle it out to get a recording contract, is one that has inspired a number of films and television shows. The trouble is that the thought is ane rooted firmly in the 1960s, when the Recording Industry Assocation of America was relevant, people's tastes were and then underdeveloped that one genre would capture most of the globe's attending, and the and then-called pinnacle ten really reflected what people were buying. But the revelations of the past xx or so years take turned that entire notion on its head. No longer practise nosotros believe that the top ten is actually a reflection of our tastes (in fact many articles take been published to the issue that the pop charts are rigged), and the RIAA no longer has sole command over how we hear artists. In fact, contained, underground recording labels accept seen their business explode tenfold since the MP3 revolution, and for the first fourth dimension in history, the advertisement of recording artists has truly get a level playing field.
All of this translates into increasing irrelevance for talent quests similar American Idol. Much of the commentary I hear nigh the show revolves around the 3 judges, who are in essence the real stars. Exercise not expect at them, withal, they are not the reason the evidence is entirely irrelevant. In fact, they are virtually the only connection the show really has to the nowadays-day market for music. Paula Abdul reflects the overly optimistic arroyo that many of the RIAA's marketeers suffer from, Randy Jackson highlights the irrelevance, and Simon Cowell repeats exactly what the more than intelligent department of the buying public is thinking. Indeed, for all the complaints about Cowell'due south cruelty, he is near the just matter worth watching the testify for because of his unflinching power to slap hopefuls in the face with reality. To quote his comments to William Hung, you cannot sing, yous cannot dance, so what practice you desire us to say? Ironically, aside from one contestant, Hung has achieved far more recognition and fame due to his uncynical, earnest attitude than anyone else who has appeared on the show.
Which brings me to the contestants themselves. To partly quote Alexei Sayle, I might be stupid similar, merely I happen to know that butchering the material of other people is never going to give a off-white indication of how much ability an artist has. Although Kelly Clarkson's post-Idol material is irrelevant to me, it also demonstrates she has enjoyed the about success of the lot because she can create something of her ain. Covers of top-forty filler songs that were not even relevant to the audience back then will prove very little. Even the option of songs is and so tepid as to be monotonous. Once you have heard ane talentless pretty face up cover Whitney Houston, you take heard them all. At to the lowest degree on the versus albums released by the black metallic hugger-mugger, they challenged each other to cover each other'southward songs, likewise as songs past an artist that they would otherwise not normally play, such every bit GGFH or Frank Zappa. Even something as straightforward as Glenn Danzig would bamboozle the imagination-challenged idiots of Idol.
The scary affair is that after ix out of x finalists fail to become so much as a mention after their term on the show is over, the powers backside it still want to blame piracy for bilious record sales. They fail to empathize something that the independents and underground long ago incorporated into their market strategy. You see, as much equally I disparage the Beatles or their ilk for being the original boy bands, they fabricated information technology big when they did because at that time, nobody had heard anything similar them. They had the correct combination of novelty and semi-solid songwriting that also propelled bands like Black Sabbath or Bathory to notoriety. Kelly Clarkson, Justin Gaurini, and everyone that has followed subsequently them, just have nothing to offer that is exceptional or unique. Xx-v years ago, when radio fare was non nearly and then narrow or limited, acts like Devo created a stir considering they pushed envelopes. Funk-punk, electronica, and punk-pop had observers that were of the same historic period then as Cowell is now asking what was next.
So when I say that the present crop of pop musicians that shows like Idol effort to promote as if they are the hottest affair since tofu are little more than a damp squib, I want you to understand my full meaning. As I stated differently in my comments about Metallicrap'southward contempo aping of Spinal Tap, the world has moved on from this kind of matter. Maybe it is time that Simon Fuller and his cronies realised this, because I am kind of certain that Simon Cowell and to a lesser extent Paula Abdul have realised information technology. Indeed, as I sit here listening to Danzig, a human who has more creativity in his fingernails than every single contestant who has been on every iteration of Idol worldwide would have in their commonage bodies, I notice something is quite rotten in the country of the music industry. While I wish Clarkson the all-time in her efforts to exploit the fame that Idol brought her, I really simply wish these people would raise their bar concurrently with the way the ears of the wider world have raised theirs. At the very least, we could become Scarlet Symons of Skyhooks fame to guess a few shows. With him and Cowell on the same panel, contestants might spontaneously combust from the ego-checks.
American Idol is a ii out of ten show. Nobody on the show salve Cowell seems to know a thing.
33 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Used to like it, just at present it is actually formulaic, tired and anticipated
No doubt in that location are some really talented singers such as David Cook, Chris Daughtry and Kelly Clarkson, but others were ludicrously bad. And then at that place were others with abrasive personalities, Tatiana I am looking at you. However, while I was addicted to it at first mainly considering of the hilarious auditions, I stopped watching it after it became increasingly formulaic, tired and anticipated.
Simon's put downs no longer became funny, instead they became increasingly insulting, and Paula became increasingly inaudible over the screaming audience. The choreography was often nether-apposite, the singers sometimes selection the wrong songs for their voice(a huge danger when it comes to singing), the lighting was dim, the clothes that some contestants wear either in auditions(ie. Bikini Girl and the guy in the Pink Rabbit conform) or on the live shows(ie. Carly) are either too revealing or unflattering and I am not a fan of Ryan Seacrest'southward presenting. Also the show is very exploitative, I know the X Factor is quite exploitative, but this brings the meaning of exploitation to a whole new level. It is non entirely the testify'southward fault though, the media are more often than not to blame too. Then there are those who don't make information technology through Hollywood or the live shows, they weep and say that American Idol is their life. Give me a pause, I am non trying to audio insensitive, merely there are many many good things you tin can do with your life other than proceed American Idol, if you really want to sing, join a pop band, a musical theatre or opera group, you may find they are amend in terms of time value.
Overall, formulaic, tired and predictable, non to mention exploitative. 2/10 for the auditions. Bethany Cox
21 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Optimistic to the Signal of Foolishness
At that place comes a time in every reasonable man's life when he must sit down in his living room and watch an episode of American Idol. Truth is I'm non a reasonable man. Or even a reasonable woman, now that I retrieve about it. I have, notwithstanding, watched an episode of American Idol and will go so far every bit to say that I accept religiously watched three seasons of information technology. Showtime season was great. Second season was skilful. During third flavor, I got wiser and realized that the testify wasn't every bit skillful anymore, but notwithstanding I watched. It had lost its magic, its X-Factor, you could say. During 4th flavor, I watched four or five episodes. By and so, I had rediscovered sitcom idiot box. At present comes fifth season, and the inevitable disappointment that lurks around the show reappears again. Yet, people notwithstanding watch the show because they are too brainwashed not to.
Then once more, what else is at that place to watch on Tuesdays? Or Wednesdays. Or Thursdays. Or any other dark of the week, for that affair. I mean, why watch anything else when I can watch the new season or reruns of past performances made readily available via my Handy-Dandy DVD player? (Yes, we bought the Best of Season One. So sue me.) I must say that American Idol has become anticipated. A "dude, man, dawg" from Randy Jackson. An "I simply want to eat you lot upward and make all our viewers sick to their stomachs with my infinite well of gaga comments" from Paula Abdul. And "Enter sarcastic, British remark hither" from Simon Cowell. Cue Ryan Seacrest'south idiotic antiphon and make-the-girls-swoon smiling. The contestants are the same: air-headed bimbos, wannabe rockers, real rockers, melt-the-camera-with-a-stare heartthrobs, belters, and the similar. For goodness sake, requite u.s. something skillful to watch again! Every now and then we get fantastic singers like Kelly Clarkson, Tamira Grey, and Clay Aiken. The rest are a little more or less than mediocre. Come up to think of it, I can't call back the last time I heard Ruben, Fantasia, or Diana on the radio. Don't even mention Justin Guarini. What a waste matter of his perfectly good talent. The merely thing Idol tin can practice for you is give you a year, if that, of fame, then send you on back home to the karaoke bars in Oneida, Tennessee. Tough interruption, kids.
Information technology is just unfair to see what they practise to these contestants. They go the same corporeality of men as they practise women to avoid whatever legal problems virtually gender bias. Completely bogus! Sometimes, there are ameliorate men than some of the women on that testify (and vice versa), so why should they be cut just so the Idol producers won't be accused of discrimination on the cover of tabloids. The real offense is letting a bunch of less-than-worthy singers get on just to balance things out. And and then some of the singers get scolded for song choices. Oh, no, Heaven forbid someone does a Mariah or a Whitney! No, no! Those are untouchable. I just have my fingers crossed that one contestant volition finally lash out at Randy, proverb, "Well, Mr. Jackson, yous give me a list of songs I'm not supposed to do, and I'll make certain I sing them all just for yous." Even if they are actually practiced, goose egg is as practiced as the original, then just give upwards.
The producers of Idol need to take a step back from the show they've created and look at what it has go: a rigged popularity competition. The just thing Idol is good for is delaying House episodes for weeks at a time. What a waste of an Emmy and Golden Earth winning show. Producers, you lot need some variety in this testify. Just keep your fingers crossed that you choose the correct Idol this time, as you seem to think that America is too intellectually inept to do then themselves. Greenlighting this overstayed-information technology'due south-welcomed show for another flavour and thinking that the aforementioned people are all the same going to dearest information technology would be optimistic to the signal of foolishness. Merely then again, what do I know? I'm just a kid with a television and a telephone.
68 out of 100 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Absolutely Ridiculous
It is wholly inexplicable and mystifying that a nation could be so obsessed with a evidence like this, a worthless, fifteen-minutes-of-fame, trashy-so-information technology'southward-bad slice of garbage that captivates more than collective attention than the average Presidential race. Constantly, I am forced to hide in my room when this show comes on because information technology overrides all other shows where I live. With newspaper-thin walls, I can hear every minute of information technology: the generic pop voices, the horrible auditions at the beginning of every season that throw desolation out the window, and the growing applesauce of the guess's sweetness, self-approbation, and ruthlessness. It is past far a more rewarding experience to picket unintelligent programs mock this bear witness than it is to watch it itself-- "Shrek ii," anyone? And "American Idol Rewind," a vapid expansion of the show'due south early years, is fifty-fifty more heinous and pointless. Yet people continue to watch the competition, from talentless winners (Kelly Clarkson, Clay Aiken, Taylor Hicks, etc.) to unique, worthwhile losers (Daughtry!) But approximate what. Even Chris Daughtry hates information technology when people mention his appearance on this show. Because it is, in its own, Idol way, a puerile, infantile, mindless and bland exercise in finding the next unlikely hero to throw through the ruthless popular civilization gum-ball machine. A word of advice to the people who actually tune in every January: go and watch the classic 1981 movie musical "Daze Treatment." Once you see its town overwhelmed to Orwellian proportions past Tv shows like this, you lot volition come across the mistake of your remote-controlled ways.
21 out of 39 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Show That Wouldn't Go Away
I've had actually no interest or even the remotest liking for the overall format of this show. I did express mirth hysterically at the kickoff 2 or iii seasons of horrible singers,just after that,I didn't intendance virtually the contest at all.
Reason existence is,in my stance,even though a selected number of these performers "exercise" have the talent,I don't feel this is a legitimate mode of hitting the big time. What,"actually" have most of these singers washed to earn or deserve to be famous? Some of them accept been in bands and played clubs,some of them take have been in schoolhouse chorus or possibly fifty-fifty washed a localized solo career just how many have truly "suffered" for their art? Practise they even see in the category of art? No,in my view.
Especially when they endeavor to practice songs before their time. Nine out of ten times,I experience no emotional connection with their renditions of classic pop & rock songs. In my view,they don't take the proper emotional connectedness to the songs themselves. Maybe because they're too young too have experienced such emotions and situations. Making their operation seem empty.
As for our resident judges? Randy and Paula Abdul practise their job wonderfully,although Paula tends to become a niggling too emotionally involved. (Although non so where Cowell is the gene.)
Simon Cowell,is almost heartless,so it seems. He ranges from brutally honest to downright insulting. Sometimes deserved in some cases,sometimes "definetly" not! Imagine,a young daughter,self-witting near herself already and he makes her experience 10 times worse about herself!
Anyhow,the show by now has get quite repetitive and not even the bad singers could brand me tune in over again. I enjoyed it a little for the things I mentioned but not anymore,I've moved on.
I'k surprised that America didn't. (Stop)
x out of sixteen found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dear God, what has go of telly?
Shows like this are the reason that so much of tv set sucks these days. It is naught more an over-hyped, overblown televised karaoke contest and people watch this crap in droves. I've totally lost all faith in humanity for allowing a show like this to go on and on and on.Years ago, a prove like this (think 'Star Search' for example) was the exception rather than the norm. At present it's all you tin can observe. Reality programming has completely ruined TV. Granted, there's nevertheless some pretty decent scripted shows on the tube (Monk, 30 Rock, My Proper noun is Earl, The Office) but equally long as people line up mindlessly to watch muck like 'American Idol', I'm afraid it'south just gonna get worse. I cry for the future.
51 out of 83 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Used to be good.
The new super short format sucks. Information technology gives goose egg time for the audience to autumn in love with the singers. Fix it.
7 out of ix establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What a joke
It'southward lamentable that and so many talented, hard-working musicians out in that location have been busting their ass for years and can't get a pause, while any soulless, talentless suburban poser can go on what is basically a nationally-televised karaoke contest, become the flavor of the month, and then be forgotten about six months later(unless y'all're Kelly Clarkson). I know it's already been said by another poster, but information technology'southward true: some of these people take played in small bands or had local solo gigs, some of them take potential, but the bulk of them are a agglomeration of wannabes with no real talent. They don't have the dedication and want it takes to build a lasting career in a notoriously fickle manufacture: they're in it for their 15 minutes of fame, and zip more.
53 out of 91 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gives "Reality" TV a whole new meaning.
If it weren't for Simon Cowell, I have to wonder how many people would scout this prove. I acknowledge this says something of my character, but he's the reason I watch this show. His blunt matter of fact, tell-it-like-is approach to telling the unvarnished truth to the no-talent wannabes who audition is something I find very refreshing. Especially when their egos and attitudes are straight proportional to the extent that they suck -- meaning the more they suck, the more ego and attitude they tend to accept. (Not with all, only certainly a lot of them) Then in that location are others who don't have attitude and are devastated by criticism and can be seen in tears afterward, and even if they were bad I feel a piddling sad for them. Just that's simply the reality, of the music business and if these kids can't handle information technology, then they shouldn't exist trying to forge a career equally a musical artist.
That'south reality, and Simon gives them this much needed reality cheque. It'southward reality TV in every sense of the word.
47 out of 79 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Simulated
Won't say who it was out of respect for their privacy, but a friend of mine went to audition for this atrocity to television.
They didn't even let this person audition. They filmed everything upward to the top 20 on the same day and made information technology look real. When everyone comes for the audition, they actually mean they're going to decide who volition really audience. They will randomly tell people they can go but because they look funny and think information technology would exist hilarious to see on TV, and don't let other people get considering they await to ordinary or they don't expect TV material. Then they let some of the people they chose sing for five seconds, and if that v seconds doesn't delight them they don't get to audition with the judges and move on. This happened with my friend.
This is INSULTING. Many artists would experience privileged to accept the opportunity to express their paintbrush for the world to see. This "opportunity" was a broken hope, never intending to be fulfilled in the start place.
Non to mention, the show only wasn't interesting.
v out of vii plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
I can only watch this testify for almost 3 minutes.
mm-39 16 February 2008
I can only watch this show for about iii minutes. I retrieve, back in the day, going to battle of the bands, and what I am picket is a televising version of the latter. I must exist getting old say dorsum in the day. The entertainment is similar to the bar bands grade B. OK but I can not watch a full hour of the testify. Another rendition of Star Search! In that location is some humor in the show; and people love to watch others bomb or go down in flames. I believe we love to watch people burn for it makes us not feel so bad about ourselves. When others stink we experience good knowing nosotros could do better or the same. I just detect the show also much hype. Simon could use a chill pill. three out of 10 Simon. Simon what are y'all doing? I guess Simon must know people for Simon's fabricated a lot of money of Idol.
4 out of seven found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Popular yes, but that doesn't brand it good . . .
Certain the show pulls loftier ratings, provokes fevered discussion and might fifty-fifty be fun for its viewers. They've assembled a tight trio of judges with skillful natured rapport and enough of a comprehensive critical centre to weed through the shallow, fame-craving riff-raff . . . however . . . I am hither to bury Idol, not to praise it! At near the evidence is a guilty pleasure, every bit hollowly insubstantial as information technology is trite. It's best fit as passive, ultimately forgettable recreation for a preadolescent audition with no other life business organization except perhaps their schoolwork. The final irony is that all of the "American Idols" picked past the judges and the viewers, with the possible exception of Carrie Underwood, have sooner or later vanished from the formerly adoring public eye that created them! Despite this repeated repudiation of its mere beingness, the ungainly behemoth that is American Idol nonetheless slouches towards us each seasonal cycle, waiting to be built-in anew in all its false idolatric 'splendor' . . .
xv out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
I enjoy it, for the most part.
This is the kickoff twelvemonth (2005)that I've watched American Idol. I surprised myself and enjoyed it. It provides a look into the process and reasons for signing a person to a contract. The only thing that I don't similar is the final weeks and how they let people know who has not made the cut. I detect it fell and unnecessary. I too notice that Simon Crowell'due south comments are pretty authentic nearly the contestants. I used to watch Star Search, with Ed McMahon, and idea that was great, but this is much more interesting. I would similar to see the handling of cutting contestants changed. I don't find this to exist a popularity contest at all. I too think that if these people cannot take the criticism that is handed to them they should not be in the amusement business organization.
25 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worst of the worst of competition shows
This is the worst of the worst of contest shows. The whole format & everything is all wrong. Like with the group round..........which is totally stupid unless your original audition was equally a group and so every contestant there is praying and hoping to win and brand their big pause as an individual, not a grouping. The Voice does it best with the battle rounds with just 2 contestants upwardly singing together. At that place is nothing fair towards or for the contestants at all on American Idol. There is a reason The Voice has been voted and rated the number ane competition show on tv set the last however many years in a row. American Idol is unfair towards all its contestants and American Idol is stupid and sucks.
3 out of four institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
With Its' Style Ups and Pretty Pathetic Downs
This prove is a reality show at centre. Thousands of people audition in front end of 3 judges, the infamous (withal truthful. People, if they're bad singers, don't arraign him!) Simon, Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul. They're mostly given the boot but some laissez passer and go through many elimination rounds until we, the viewers, get to vote and slowly one-by-one toss out the terminal ten until nosotros get one American Idol.
The outset episodes are definitely the ones that spark its' popularity. As an exchange for a gratis contract deal, Pull a fast one on is allowed to videotape and broadcast anyone they want.
This is the five, 000+ auditioning stage. With then many people of so many cities, nosotros've got to discover at to the lowest degree a dozen people who retrieve they can sing. I'm talking about the bad ones. Emphasize on Call back.
It's sad when they say they've ever had a singing dream and are atrocious. But it'due south hilarious when people outburst because they now THOUGHT (or all the same call up) they can sing. I guy on a contempo flavor two episode idea he deserved to exist the American Idol 'cause he thought he could sing and he stood out five days in the cold. As well bad he sounded like a bird being strangled.
There was another one of the same episode who said he had a dream(so far sad) of being a vocalizer. He sings, and puts way too much into it(he'south trying to sound like Enrique Glasias", and is turned downward(notwithstanding sad). He's OK, though, and walks out with a grinning(right now confusing). He and then walks out and proclaims to everyone he'due south going to Hollywood(the next round)(a niggling funny). About an audition later, the camera finds him sitting waiting for an audition. He explains to the security guard with the cameraman he's been invited back(at present funny). As this never happens, the security baby-sit doesn't hesitate to correct him and boots him out(kinda funny). He yells while leaving(the security baby-sit lets him walk out himself) "I'll run across you lot all in Hollywood!".(funny)
One last one, a daughter couldn't believe they said she was but under average, good only hidden in a crowd of a choir. She denies being turned down, and when the host(with proof) asks her didn't she become refused Hollywood, she states she doesn't know, and tries to get back in to discover out. One thing: she's a terrible liar. For ratings, she's allowed dorsum in. Simon asks her hadn't they already seen her. She conspicuously wants a 2nd chance, but strangely tries to offset with (perhaps the host was there) "I wanted to know if I'm going to Hollywood". "No, because y'all're terrible.". And it ends.
The second round is OK, as the crowd of about 200 is brought down to 30. The people who don't make it go a chance to speak out.
Afterwards that, nosotros start voting, while the judges provide their thoughts. In a clearly planned move, you take away the bad singers now, and wind upwardly with audience interaction. Information technology's not the same, but you still run across ane vote and wonder how many people are trying to mess information technology all up by purposely trying to air current up with a bad vocalizer winning.
I really bask the showtime parts more than. Merely it's truly speechless. You have to run into information technology to believe it.
24 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Most pointless show ever made...
I tin can't believe that people willfully watch this bear witness. It'south such a waste of fourth dimension watching people embarrass themselves on national television. Shows like this i are the reason why America is total of morons and the reason why the Chinese and Japanese are going to own this country in the coming decades. The only reason shows similar this are fifty-fifty on t.v. is the fact that corporate television executives are so greedy that instead of making t.v. shows that at the very to the lowest degree give a wholesome bulletin or bring sensation to the public about a certain bug they look for any way to squeeze every penny they can and stick it in their own pockets instead of spending information technology on something worthwhile or educational. Don't watch shows like this. Read a book instead. Spend time with your kids. Become an pedagogy. Practice something worthwhile with your life.
22 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Please get away
I enjoyed the show in the first couple of seasons and enjoyed some of the products that came from this show. Merely, information technology is time for this bear witness to go abroad. I know I have an unpopular view, but I am sick and tired of 3 days of programming existence taken up for this seemingly endless parade of over inflated egos and a line up of people whom I never desire to see on TV always once again. Non to mention the relentless beating of the expressionless horse with Idol Rewind and the hours spent on showcasing the worst of the worst in American Karaoke. There has to exist a better manner for these kids to be discovered and/or rejected than taking upward our fourth dimension and patience. Delight go quietly into that skillful night and don't look back. I retrieve the American public is ready for scripted dramas and comedies again.
7 out of 10 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The simply "reality show" that I intendance well-nigh.
I have been an avid "American Idol" fan since its inception. I loved that Kelly Clarkson won the kickoff i. I thought Dirt Aiken should accept won the second one (statistically he and Reuben were virtually tied, and the winner was probably a artifact of the phone voting limitations). While I retrieve highly of Reuben, as a singer he simply isn't good enough to sustain a career with it. And, during the 3rd season, fifty-fifty though I initially didn't care for Fantasia's style of singing, I eventually came on board and thought she was a worthy winner. And then that tells me American voters become it right ... eventually.
"American Idol" is the simply reality show I watch. I have always had a fascination with keen singers. I am a competent singer, but could never have made it as a featured artist. And so, to see these young women and young men letting it all hang out, singing from their souls, gives me chills. Some of them are unbelievably good.
This twelvemonth is virtually over, with 5 contestants left as of last dark (May iii, 2005). There has been controversy, just one of them will emerge as the winner and have their outset dream fulfilled, the beginning of a professional singing career. Where it goes from there depends on how good they really are. Making a living as a vocaliser is a tough business, in that location are so many skilful ones.
(As an bated, my good friend and neighbour Larry had a chance meeting with Simon Cowell last fall, at a grocery shop in London. They spoke a minute, Larry institute Simon to be very pleasant and congenial, not at all similar the persona he adopts on the prove.)
five out of 10 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worst testify ever
How such a shallow and pathetic show can succeed so much? Making fun of people that expect weird and build a career to talentless shallow people like Kelly Clarckson, has nothing to do with music. This show kills music. And it got 5.0 stars here! This thing should get a ZERO! The funny matter is that just people who look expert, tin win it. The massage this show tries to tell is: merely ignorant shallow and, of course BEAUTIFUL people can be what they telephone call "singers". This is painful to watch. Reality-junk TV show like this should become canceled, I tin't believe this show still runs, when at that place are many other good shows out at that place that become canceled. Don't waste your fourth dimension on this thing. Just a recommendation.
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This show is corrupt, overdone and unnecessary
I hate this bear witness with a passion. At commencement information technology was a good idea and picked a skilful singer. When saying there was going to be another ane, i though "Ok i guess America could take *two* idols..." just when Rubin won, i knew this was a corrupt prove that only cares about image. I was then happy when people began voting for the worst. This show deserves it. And the judges have no purpose if the show is "determined" by America. Randy's "yo yo yo" is just old and annoying, Paula as the "dainty ane" is quickly becoming annoying, Simons sarcastic British comments are becoming overly done and Ryan Seacrest is mayhap *the* most annoying host on goggle box. He is so full of himself and has no identify in the bear witness. People should know by now that the show is decadent and that "America" tin can't vote for their life.
14 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It Has Improved.
American Idol has gotten a lot of hate since it it began. Why? What's so bad nigh information technology? It started in the early on 2000s when you needed talent to make information technology big and your image was changed alone. It was singing talent scouts that people may never take gotten the chance to ever come across. A time to make a dream a reality.
It started off with brutally honest British judge, Simon Cowell; hip and cool onetime Journey drummer, Randy Jackson; and quondam pop diva and dancer, Paula Abdul. Information technology was funny to run into Simon trash everybody, Paula praise everybody and Randy be chilling. Ryan Seacrest has e'er been a great host. Superstars were made and fantastic singers emerged.
But things got a turn for the worse when Paula decided to depart. Ignorant judges were coming in that shouldn't exist at that place like Ellen Degenerous. Simon's farewell seemed to exist the offset of a new affiliate. Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez joined Randy on the judging table. That was Idol'due south best year equally there was not i bad contestant. Just as things were getting hot, the show declined to the point where I was sure information technology would never recover. Keith Urban, Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey replaced Tyler and Lopez for the worst yr. Minaj and Carey had no idea what they were doing and they ruined the show.
All was saved when J-Lo returned to replace Minaj and Carey and Harry Connick Jr. replaced Randy. Now we have three talented judges that know their stuff. Idol is now the show information technology used to be.
3 out of 5 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
American Snow Job
American Idol, amounts to the same one-time same onetime talent testify, repackaged and fancied upwards for your viewing amusement. Oh yes, and the audience does get to phone in and cast their vote, which probably accounts for much of the popularity of this weekly song fest.
American Idol travels the country holding tryouts for tens of thousands idol wannabe'due south in several major cities through out the U.S. Contestants have been known to wait in line for days in hopes to get their large break. It is never made clear how some of these people are chosen to audition. The producers seem to want a mix of the very atrocious, the just OK, and the very good. The actually awful ones are meant to entertain us in the preliminary rounds then that we can ridicule them along with the judges. Of all these early on contestants, only 119 were picked to become to Hollywood to try and get one of the called 32. We are led to believe that these 119 are hand picked by the judges Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson. However, it is never made articulate to u.s. whether these judges sat and watched every single one of the tryouts, or how much input the producer of the testify has into who makes information technology and who doesn't.
Once in Hollywood, the final 119 are given several tasks to perform in order to bear witness their worthiness of becoming one of the 32 finalists. Information technology was at this betoken that I began to smell a rat. Commencement off, these tasks were not only unfair, but there was little logic in assigning them. For instance, each contestant was given a list of song subjects. From this list they had to choose on item, write a song near it and perform it the next 24-hour interval. Since there is no requirement that yous take to be able to write a song to be an Idol, the task didn't make much sense to me. Sensing that virtually of America was probably equally puzzled as I was, the host Ryan Secrest, explained it wasn't important as to whether or not the song was whatsoever good, it was to come across how each contestant did nether force per unit area. That would have been acceptable merely when it came fourth dimension to perform, the comments of the judges had picayune or zero to practise with that aspect of information technology. For instance, ane contestant had written some rather clever lyrics and performed them quite well. She was able to practise this whereas many contestants couldn't even call up the words to the songs they had written. Yet, Simon criticized her past asking her if she wanted to be a comedienne or a vocaliser. The contestant seemed to be as taken aback as I was. How good the song was or what the song was near was not supposed to be an issued. She had performed well under pressure level just it didn't thing. So much for fairness in this round.
The side by side task that each contestant had to get with two other contestants and perform a song together. This didn't brand a whole lot of sense either and seemed even more ridiculous than the songwriting contest. If a contestant happened to get paired with two other good singers it made them expect good. All the same, there were several unlucky skilful singers who were paired with mediocre contestants who refused to even do.
When the 32 are picked nosotros are given no reasons or criteria equally to how they were judged. The girl Simon called a clown was history, although she had performed admirably at every phase. In her concluding appearance when she performed solo, she toned down her vivaciousness and performed an outstanding number. After she was finished, Simon, who had earlier asked her if she wanted to be a comedienne or a vocalizer, now called her boring. Get figure. Two brothers who had also performed with mediocrity throughout the Hollywood auditions also made the final 32. There were other numerous unexplained choices, too many to even begin to pick apart here. Again we are non told if the three judges had the concluding say so or whether the shows producers or whoever had input into the conclusion.
The contestant the judges have heaped the most praise on has ever moved on. The second contestant that has moved on has been kind of like a ringlet of the dice, in that location is never any certainty well-nigh information technology. Call me a cynic if yous will, merely I find it strange that the phone-in votes has always agreed with the judges on their outset option. You would call up that at some betoken just by figuring the odds that this wouldn't happen every week. It can only lead 1 to 2 possible conclusions: 1. Either the American viewing public is a race of sheep unable to decide for themselves who they think is best or 2. There's some monkey business going on with the voting on this prove. Neither choice is very palatable, particularly when yous consider some of the decisions made by the judges.
There are another hard fast rules to remember nearly American Idol. Get-go, never sing a slow vocal if you lot can get around it. No matter how proficient you are or how good you may sing, it is the kiss of expiry. You will be called either boring, a lounge vocalizer, a café singer, or someone who is unwilling to accept chances. 2d, despite what I said above, never have chances or be original. These judges frown on it. 1 vocalist who took a risk on a jazz number was rapidly banished considering it wasn't the type of song the judges were looking for. That she sang and performed well didn't thing. Third, when you get to the end of your vocal, sing very very loud, and hold your terminal note every bit long equally y'all can. These are certain fire audience pleaser's and the judges eat it up. Proof of this tin exist institute in each of the contestants that the judges have lavished their highest praises on in the first 3 weeks of flavor three.
There is enough more wrong with this evidence, and I could write a thousand more words about information technology. All I tin say is melody in, accept an open mind, and inquire some questions nearly legitimacy. Somebody should.
My Grade F
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Too Contrived To Be Watchable TV
Add-on - I am incorrect about this lasting as the show has changed judges and refreshed itself. The big reason the testify is still on is the talent it keeps finding. In that location are a lot of talented singers out there, a supply that volition keep this show fresh year to year. While the big ratings days are behind it, American Idol volition continue going for a while yet.
I decline to believe so much of the American Public likes this drivel. In fact the ratings are starting to drop because it is wearing sparse in the skin. In some other twelvemonth or two, this testify will be yesterdays news.
Simon was a breath of fresh air at first, but at present has go must get abroad from personality. He wears out faster than a new used car. Ryan Seachrist is a Dick Clark wanna be but he too has had a short shelf life as his daytime TV show flopped fast. Forget Randy & Paula, they are excess baggage.
For some reason, this show is referred to equally Reality TV which also includes such drivel as CBS'due south Survivor. The intellectuals(?) who practise that are in deprival. These shows are really Prime number Time Soap Operas latest incarnation. The only reason you watch is yous get hooked by the people who are on the testify.
Trouble with Idol is that every year brings more of the same. The same wears out in this format fast. Some of these elements are used in Deal or No Deal which is dislocated with a Game show.
There is piddling reality here. In fact the format is they shoot the live results evidence every week & after the alive role is over immediately tape the performing show for the next week. This way they know who is left & do non accept to go the audience in to the studio for 2 shows.
The show has been known to fake a lot of early on sequences, & mistreats wannabes because instead of judging the ones who make the finals by talent, they choice their contestants by personality for hooking the viewers. They also borrowed ABC Sports Roone Arledge creations of doing little BIOS of the finalists.
Overall, unless you want to watch a certain contestant or are a Simon type person, this show has no interest for viewing. Even the music is very often also canned & karaoke like. Thank goodness Paula hasn't sang on information technology. I've got one of her erstwhile tapes, she can't sing just she sure could trip the light fantastic & strut her stuff back then.
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0319931/reviews
0 Response to "After Watching Win American Idol I Never Doubted His ​medal Again"
Enregistrer un commentaire